FILM: The Oscars: So the King was King

Like the King, I was a little speechless

It has taken me a few days for the commentary about this.  Even though I enjoyed The King's Speech (it is my top rated film so far in 2011), I was still disappointed for the overlooking of The Social Network & David Fincher.  How did this happen? and why?... my theories below.

Ahead of its time
The film really has to be placed in the context of the Academy crowd.  Don't know a lot about them and how one becomes eligible to vote (think you have to win one, or be special), but my impression is they are all a thousand + years old and possibly not attune with the facebook phenomenon.  Some might not even have accounts (god forbid), so an awareness of its magnitude and scope may have been missed there, (much like Larry Summers in one of the best scenes in the film).  Sigh.  A year from now the oldies will all be on to the thing, singing its praises.  Being first in this case, probably wasn't everything (also from the film).

The anti-feel good, anti-hero
The other point is that its not a particularly uplifting film, nor one that'll have you crying.  At it's core it's a story about a couple of friends who come up with a great idea, that eventually tears them apart.  The less than heroic protagonist on which its based, completely betrays his friend for the sake of the beast (debatable), and ends up alone, despite his riches.  Intriguing as hell, yes.  But up against a stuttering King who just wants to get a few good words out?... it's a contest mismatch.

Timing is everything... sorry, repeating lines
The studio may have gone for money, instead of gone for gold in the release of this film.  I'm guessing supposedly it was to hit the facebook generation audience, but it did mean that it was a bit early for awards season which may have taken away some of its momentum.  Fincher's films for the last few years have been Oscar worthy, and he should now be backed with a release date to compliment its deserved accolades.  It is a money game however, and these considerations don't often apply.

Does it matter in the greater scheme of things?  Yes and no.  Sad for Fincher, as it is the ultimate recognition in the business, but the film itself will endure and stand apart through the test of time.  His films are already part of course curriculum in many institutions (Se7en and Fight Club both part of mine) and The Social Network will no doubt be added to the list.  That in the world of filmmaking, is permanence, and allows screen gems like that to live forever.

PS: Was glad that it got Best Score and also glad that The Inside Job got Best Documentary! Down with the bankers! :)